Understand Collective Curation
Robin Good on the Need for Curation Online
Joyce' VOYA Article on Pathfinder Tools
My personal favorite wiki creation tool is Wikispaces for teachers. (I know that others prefer and swear by PB Works.) The folks at Wikispaces give teachers free, ad-free wiki sites. Just remember to click on the button that identifies you as a K12 educator to remove any pesky ads.
You can easily create a wiki index to keep track of your growing collection of wiki pathfinders. For me, what began as one simple little library wiki, turned into a network of hundreds of wikis linked together, and linking to other content in other formats. In fact, I’ve noticed that many libraries that use blogs as a dynamic front page interface, turn to wikis for their pathfinder platform.
Wikis continue to be one of my own preferred platforms, but we now have so many choices, and in a world of remix, we are no longer limited to a single platform. Our pathfinders can be a crazy quilt of multiple platforms that to the user or student appear completely unified. I asked some of the geekiest teacher librarians I know to share their favorite pathfinder platforms.
Proponents of Wikis:
When I polled my colleagues about their tools of choice, wikis were a clear favorite; they were the go-to platform.
Elementary librarian Keisa Williams has placed several of her wiki-based pathfinders on our sharing portal, Pathfinder Swap (http://pathfinderswap.wikispaces.com). Keisa’s site is the wiki-based Monarch Library (http://monarchlibrary.wikispaces.com), and she works to make her wiki pathfinders fun and interactive for her elementary students. On her own pathfinder portal (http://monarchlibrary.wikispaces.com/pathfinders), are pathfinders like Black History For Kids pathfinder: http://monarchlibrary.wikispaces.com/blackhistoryforkids. Keisa is also responsible for co-founding Elementary Library Routines Wiki- http://elementarylibraryroutines.wikispaces.com.
Anne-Marie Gordon, a school library media specialist in upstate NY, uses PBWorks as her tool of choice, and often embeds an attractive Glog in the center space of her wikis. Her pathfinder menu (https://squareone.pbworks.com/w/page/12301583/MediaTeatime) leads young researchers to engaging guide pages like these:
- Elephants http://squareone.pbwiki.com/Elephants
- Giraffe http://squareone.pbwiki.com/Giraffes
- Kangaroos http://squareone.pbwiki.com/Kangaroos
California librarian, Marie Slim (Fullerton Joint Union School District), is also a wiki believer, for their ease of use and their remarkable embedding powers. Marie shared a few of her favorite wiki creations:
- Synthesis Research Project: http://fjuhsdlibraries.wikispaces.com/Synthesis+Research+Project+-+Hollon
- Bee unit Knowledge Building Center: http://fuhsag.wikispaces.com/
- Math Animation/Movie Knowledge Building Center: http://fuhsmath.wikispaces.com/
- WebQuest on Weisel’s Night with student products: http://fuhsnight.wikispaces.com/ (based on a WebQuest from Toni DeJaco-McKee of Campbell County High School in Alexandria, KY)
Lisa Perez wrote to share the work of Inter-American School (Chicago Public Schools) librarian, Francis Feeley. Lisa explains that Fran’s examples “epitomize what we hope for in a good electronic pathfinder. He has blended online databases, embedded forms, wikis, glogs, slideshows, and streaming media – all framed around essential questions in a wiki. His school, Inter-American Magnet School, is rather interesting, as they are dual language and redesigned the entire schedule of the school to accommodate projects like this.”
- Power and Protest in America: http://iamslibrary.wikispaces.com/grados+7%C2%BA+8%C2%BA++7th+8th+grades+Q2
- If America Were a Village: http://iamslibrary.wikispaces.com/7%C2%BA+8%C2%BA+grados-7th+8th+grades+Q1
- Teen Health & Wellness: Real Life, Real Answers: http://iamslibrary.wikispaces.com/7th+8th+3rd+OD+Wellness
- Los símbolos patrios o nacionales de los países de América: http://iamslibrary.wikispaces.com/6%C2%BA+grado-6th+grade
NetVibes and PageFlakes (maybe)
These platforms, often referred to as start pages or dashboards, easily aggregate feeds, widgets, text, and all sorts of embeddable media on convenient and dynamic publishable pages. Netvibes allows you to easily create multiple dashboards built on aggregated feeds and widgets or anything else you can embed—video, slides, ebooks, etc. While Pageflakes had been one of my favorite platforms for newsy-type pathfinders for nearly a year, the site currently seems to be unreliable and I am in the process of migrating away.
- Tokyo International School Web Wonderland: http://www.netvibes.com/tislibrary#Library
- Discovery College Online Resources: http://www.netvibes.com/discoverycollegelibrary#DC_Library
Google Sites has become a popular platform for convenient, flexible, and full-blown Web site building. It offers a gallery of attractive templates, and, of course, it plays nice with all other Google apps.
Jessica Hinman used Google Sites to create a pathfinder for fans of Artemis Fowl to explore the books’ themes. The Josiah Bartlett (NH) Elementary School uses Google Sites for both the library site and to host its wide array of PDF pathfinders designed in collaboration with classroom teachers. Janice Mudgett, Librarian and her assistant, Meghan Murphy, find Google Sites user-friendly and easy to update. Janice says, “It looks professional and I would highly recommend it to any librarian.”
Google Sites is a rich open space for building and hosting far more than the basic pathfinder. David Loertscher offers a fabulous model for Knowledge Building Centers, spaces that make the inquiry and research processes transparent, reflective, and interactive.
- Google Sites
- Model for Knowledge Building Centers
- Learning Commons Examples
- JBES Library Pathfinders
- Artemis Fowl
Perhaps best known as an online multimedia poster-making tool, Glogster, for many of us, functions also as pathfinder building tool or as an index for our pathfinders. GlogsterEDU allows users to gather all sorts of content–text, photos, videos, graphics, sounds, drawings, data and more—into attractive posters that are easily embedded in other platforms. Glogster plays especially nice with Wikispaces. (It’s an official embedding choice, under posters.) My own homepage is actually a Glog embedded in a wiki. Don’t miss Doug Valentine’s (aka Dr. Loopy) U.S.S. McKillop Elementary Library page. The site and many of Doug’s amazing media book reviews and student projects are gathered together on cleverly designed Glogs.
- U.S.S. McKillop Library Database http://mckilloplibrary.edu.glogster.com/mckillop-home/
- Springfield Virtual Library http://springfieldlibrary.wikispaces.com
- Google Search Tools Poster http://springfieldlibrary.wikispaces.com/Google+Search+Options
- BookLeads http://bookleads.wikispaces.com/
- KidSearch http://springfieldlibrary.wikispaces.com/KidSearch2
LiveBinders are hot and they are growing quickly in popularity. This very flexible app allow users to collect, share, annotate, and attractively display resources of all sorts– Web pages, PDFs, images, videos, texts: in a kind of three-ring binder or container metaphor. Items may be organized into tabs and sub-tabs. You can put your LiveBinders inside of other LiveBinders and embed your LiveBinders in other platforms. I recently created my first LiveBinder of the tools mentioned in this piece. And it was love at first site. Tiffany Whitehead, Teacher-Librarian at Central Community School System in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, says that her students are “using the heck” out of her Research & Citations LiveBinder. Joquetta Johnson, of Milford Mill Academy (MD) says that her LiveBinders are a big hit with both teachers and students. She’s a fan of their ease of use, the bookmarklet feature, the custom layouts, easy embeddability and the sharing options. And she’s gathered an impressive shelf of examples.
LiveBinders are also the tool of choice for Karen Bolotin, who teaches art, reading, and writing at Chicago Public Schools. Karen and many others recently shared their love of LiveBinders on a Classroom 2.0 webinar. Everything you need to know about the LiveBinders platform and many inspiring examples are archived. In fact, Classroom 2.0 appears to have adopted LiveBinders as an archive space for their resource-rich webinars.
- Classroom 2.0 LiveBinders Session http://livebinders.wordpress.com/2011/02/27/classroom-2-0-show/
- LiveBinder of LiveBinder examples http://livebinders.com/play/play_or_edit?id=59592
- Research & Citations http://livebinders.com/play/play_or_edit?id=55701
- Art LiveBinder http://livebinders.com/play/present?id=44622
- Black History Month LiveBinder http://livebinders.com/play/present?id=39509
- Response to Intervention (Michael Fisher) http://livebinders.com/play/play_or_edit?id=43783
- Google Apps for Educators (Joquetta Johnson) http://livebinders.com/play/play/3803
- Joquetta Johnson’s LiveBinder Pathfinders http://livebinders.com/shelf/search_author?terms=joquetta
- Odyssey http://livebinders.com/play/play_or_edit/9419
- Joyce’s LiveBinder of Pathfinder Tools http://livebinders.com/edit?id=78429
Blogs present a dynamic interface, the ability to interact with readers and keep things fresh. Carolyn Foote of Westlake High School in Austin, Texas, makes a compelling argument for blogs as a pathfinder platform in her January 2, 2010 SLJ article Looking to Ramp Up Your Library Web Site? Try a Blog. “For a while, I’d been thinking that my library site had grown pretty static. Sure, I kept it updated, but I had this notion that the content had to somehow look the same each time students visited it. Meanwhile, I kept thinking of the dynamic sites that students use routinely and wondered if maybe I could ramp things up to really capture their interest and keep them coming by the library page more often.” Like wikis, blogs allow you to play with widgets and embed nearly everything.
- Dr. Charles Best Secondary School Library Teacher Projects (Judith Comfort) http://www.bestlibrary.org/best_teachers/
- Big House Library Links (Anna Koval) http://www.bighouselibrary.com/teacher-projects.html
Blog Pathfinder Options
Social bookmarking tools can act as pathfinders. I rely on Diigo for my own personal learning updates, and, although I haven’t yet used it with my students, I plan to. Many of my colleagues use Diigo as a tool for collaborative research. Diigo offers teacher accounts and allows groups of learners to collect and organize resources and to share, sticky note, annotate, highlight resources and collaborate on research.
And then there are a growing variety of thumbnail gathering tools and Web tours.
Gwyneth Jones, of Murray Hill Middle School (MD), aka the Daring Librarian, introduced me to Sqworl. In a recent blog post: Sqworl is More Tasty than Delicious! Gwynethnotes shared how effectively the site produces pathfinders of thumbnails with shortened URLs. In blog mode, Sqworltracks the RSS feed of a page, and mode the site indicates when your sites have been updated. It also tracks views and stats. A handy bookmarlet allows you to add sites and descriptions to a Sqworl page on the fly.
Gwyneth shared a lovely instructional poster detailing Sqworl’s features.
Joyce’s Sqworl of Pathfinder Building Tools http://sqworl.com/uoc9jw
Gwyneth Jones’ Animation Sites and Education Resources http://sqworl.com/gnvsck
Additive Tech Crisps for Education http://sqworl.com/lviewf
I’ve been using Only2Clicks for several months and have created a variety of thumbnail pathfinders for our more visual topics. Students seem to like this visual format (similar to Sqworl) and have come to recognize the thumbnail interfaces of their favorite sites.
- Joyce’s full menu http://www.only2clicks.com/pages/joycevalenza/331334
- Copyright-Friendly Portals http://only2clicks.com/pages/joycevalenza/343504
- Digital Storytelling Tools http://only2clicks.com/pages/joycevalenza/331334
- Joyce’s Only2Clicks Pathfinder of Pathfinder Building Tools http://only2clicks.com/pages/joycevalenza/402582
I’ve played around a bit with Weblist as a pathfinder tool and I also like to use it when presenting research options live at conferences or during lessons. It’s got visual appeal and it gathers links, files, videos, documents and more into one URL.
- Joyce’s Weblist of Pathfinder Building Tools http://weblist.me/pathfinder-tools
- Copyright-Friendly Image Search http://weblist.me/copyright-friendly-image-search
- American Colonies http://weblist.me/american-colonies
- Leadership http://weblist.me/leadership10
- Interactive White Board Resources http://weblist.me/iwb-resources-0
Create a matrix of tiles, or webmixes for individual or shared use—with friends or with the world. I’ve only begun to play with this one, but my friend Buffy Hamilton recently blogged about its use with students (http://theunquietlibrarian.wordpress.com/2011/03/18/comparing-symbaloo-and-netvibes-as-information-dashboards-and-ples/) and is currently maintaining a LibGuide on her Symbaloo resources http://www.theunquietlibrary.libguides.com/symbaloo
It looks promising and attractive, though it does not offer embed features. And it seems that RSS feeds and Web sites must live on separate webmixes.
Examples are available on the matrix on the home site.
Other interesting bookmarking/webtour sites mentioned by my colleagues include:
- SpeedyMarks: My Visual Bookmarks http://www.speedymarks.com/
- BonzoBox http://bonzobox.com
- Middlespot http://middlespot.com/index.php#
- Jogtheweb http://jogtheweb.com
Paying for a platform?
Although I am a huge fan of free Web-based tools, I have recently begun to migrate a lot of my pathfinder content to LibGuides. The pay service offers a few distinct advantages at a reasonable price.
Why pay for a platform with all those free options? Well, I’ve been burned a few times this year, most notably by the flickering unreliability of PageFlakes. I spend a lot of time building pathfinders and other guides for my learners and teachers. I need to be able to rely on my platform. And I want that platform to grow with me and changes in the information landscape.
I’ve been playing with LibGuides for a couple of months now and I have fallen deeply in love.
- I can embed like crazy, combining my own content–my documents, handouts, advice, with dynamic widgets and feeds and video and search boxes.
- I can borrow from the brilliance of a community of other librarian creators.
- I can flexibly move my boxes around a page and copy them on multiple pages.
- I can customize my pages with color, font, and my own banner branding
- I can build a rather complicated network of pathfinders using tabs and subtabs
- I can invite multiple editors (like teachers, my practicum students, our volunteers)
- There is support. Unlike the confusion you feel when your favorite free tool just up and disappears or surprisingly goes down or adds unexpected premium prices. There are a multitude of models and options and templates for sharing in the LibGuides Community Site. There’s a Springshare Lounge for user discussions, a support blog. thorough FAQs, phone and email support, and webinars!
- I am exploring new features like mobile apps, a browser button for easy additions, Twitter and Facebook news and updates, and a link checker.
- For a reasonable price I can rely on the survival of my professional content.
- Wisconsin Hills Middle School
- Unquiet Library @ Creekview High SchoolRundlett Middle SchoolJunior
- Biology Guide @ Philips Academy
- Deerfield Academy Guides
- LibGuides at Brisbane Grammar School
- Springfield Township Databases and Portals
- Springfield Township Research Process Guide
- Springfield Township New Tools
But Really, It’s Not about One Platform
Note: I fall in love easily. But, the beauty of all this variety is that you do not have to settle for one platform.
Although consistency is nice, I’ve discovered that I don’t want to limit myself to one tool. Different tools do different things best. My pathfinder needs run the gamut—from quick lists of links to fully-developed curricular spaces and knowledge building centers. Sometimes a page of visual thumbnails does the trick. Sometimes I want to surround a simple pathfinder with a collaboratively-designed learning activity, with written guidance and advice, with media, with links to our students’ own project spaces, with artifacts of completed student work. Sometimes I need to create something beautiful and use my space in ways one tool cannot offer.
And so . . .
All the content I have on Only2Clicks, has found a home as screenshots in the boxes of my LibGuides pathfinders. My pathfinder glogs are also embedded in those boxes and on my wikis. My LibGuides are linked to my wikis. I plan to use LiveBinders and Sqworl to support upcoming student projects. My Virtual Library wiki offers widgets leading to our LibGuides pathfinders. This variety is largely invisible to my users.*
Sure, you may have to select one starting point, or a preferred parking lot, but to me it makes sense to mash-up your pathfinders, to decide what platform works best for a particular task, and to embed one tool into another.
And, after years of creating Web-based pathfinders, it occurred to me that I wasn’t the only one out there doing this work. As a profession, we continue to reinvent wheels when we could instead build on each others’ best work, discover new resources more quickly, and share models of effective practice.
Please consider sharing your own examples of effective pathfinder practice on Pathfinder Swap and the School Library Websites Wiki.
- Pathfinder Swap
- School Library Websites
- Buffy Hamilton’s Touring an Unquiet Library Research Pathfinder, a video explaining the collaborative process of creating a pathfinder with teachers: http://theunquietlibrarian.wordpress.com/2010/11/04/touring-an-unquiet-library-research-pathfinder/
Readings on curation
Students Becoming Curators of Information Langwitches (Silvia Tolisano)
Summer Seed Ideas: Curation, Participation, and Student PLEs Buffy Hamilton
Is Content Curation the New Black? Jonathan Fields, Psychology Today
5 Models of Content Curation, Rohit Bhargava
Real-Time News Curation is a nice collection by Robin Good.
I’m a curator. David Deubelbeiss
3 Reasons Curation is Here to Stay ReadWriteWeb.
Buffy Hamilton on Challenges of Curating & Sharing Database Content
Some basic rules
1. Pick your "parking lot"
2. You don't need to master all the choices!
3. Tools place nice together/mash-ups are good
4. Redundancy is good
5. Use the good stuff you have
6. Involve the talents of your partners
7. Use/celebrate student work and talent
8. Curation can be creative.